Webmasters Corner - A biweekly column on web design, usability and direction.

Leaning on the Clipart Crutch
June 27, 2005

We all have them. CDs of bad clipart. Bookmarks of royalty-free gif archives, saved "just in case." Just in case of what? When, if ever, should you use a ready-made image? The short and simple answer is... never. A unique image that the user hasn't seen before is without question a better choice than something pulled from a royalty-free gif archive or cd.

 

 

Has anything struck you as funny or tacky about this week's column yet? You're probably smiling, laughing, or shaking your head at all of these obnoxious animated gifs.

However, if you are thinking, "wow, those are pretty cool, I'd like to use that..." it's a good thing you're reading this! Using gifs like this is an instant sign of amateurism. Using an overabundance of them is ridiculous. It not only gives the impression that you were too lazy to create images that fit the unique theme of your site -- it may also be unethical if you merely found the gifs and "stole" them from someone else's site. (In this case, these gifs are all royalty-free, but you won't catch me using them outside this column..!)

Unfortunately, we've all seen websites with a bunch of distracting, rotating, animations that don't fit the theme of the site they appear on. Worse yet, we've seen them so many times that they've lost whatever "cool" effect they might have once had. Animations can be effective if used in a subtle manner. These animations are not subtle... they're annoying.

Sadly, we are all going to have web clients who surf around, pick up what they perceive to be a "cool" image, and insist that we use it on their site. Why they wouldn't want a custom image or animation that's more appropriate to their page is beyond me... but that's another question for another day. If at all possible, try to advise them that a custom image that hasn't been seen before is a much better alternative.

(I won't be burdening you with clipart through the rest of this column. I think I've made my point.)

Beginning web developers often ask for my honest opinion of their work, and it's always hard to find nice things to say when their "work" is a page littered with animations like the ones above. When told that the page would be a lot better without the clipart animations, they usually get very defensive.

I realize that not everyone out there is a pro with graphics software. You don't need a lot of graphics to have a good site. If you're not good with graphics, don't use them yet. It's much better to have a simple site with good content than a gaudy site with no content. Look around you -- some of the most-used sites on the web, like Yahoo and Google, have very few graphics at all. On the web, content is key, and making it look nice is secondary.

So, the original question remains: When, if ever, should you use a ready-made image?

If the site you're creating needs an image to convey a point, and the client does not provide one: I love clients who provide images for their sites. Pictures tell a story. For example, photos of a brick-and-mortar store can convey trust for online shoppers - they see the store, and the photo lends legitimacy to their potential purchase.

However, many clients have a concept in mind that they simply don't have photos of, and as a designer, you'll be expected to deliver what they have in their minds. We did a site for a school once which asked for a chalkboard... then an apple.. then some office supplies, pencils, erasers, staplers. The client knows what they want -- it's your job to somehow deliver it.

For times like this, it's wise to invest in a few well-chosen cds of photos and art. With photos that are royalty-free, once you purchase them, you can use them however you like. Corbis.com also has an online catalog where you can purchase royalty-free photos right on the internet.

Whichever you choose, never surf around on the net and steal images. You'll be branded not only as an amateur but also a thief, and you never know what images are copyrighted. It's very easy to embed a digital watermark that's invisible to the eye, and even after heavy modification, the watermark will still be a part of the photograph. Do you really want to be slapped with a lawsuit for stealing someone else's image?

Once you have a library of art and photo cds, use them sparingly. It's too easy to slide into the clipart trap, relying on the cds for images instead of using or creating custom ones. Use the cds as a tool, not a template. Obviously, the best scenario is to get actual photos of your customer's products, place of business or employees. But if you can't, a well-selected ready-made image can work well if used effectively.

Summary:

* Never use a ready-made image when you have or can make a custom one.
* An image that the user hasn't seen before is always better than a tired, overused image.
* Break the free animated gif habit (especially in large quantities!)
* If you're just starting out, invest in one or two royalty-free photo cds to use when client's photos aren't available.


Webmaster's Corner is written biweekly by Jill Cataldo, Senior Web Developer for NewRamp.com. She has been working in web development since 1996. Articles are copyright ©2005 NewRamp and may not be reproduced without permission.

Visit the Webmaster's Corner Articles Archive

NewRamp.com offers web hosting and technical support that is second to none. We guarantee 99.99% uptime for your site!

 

about us      |      hosting      |      tools      |      support      |      contact us       |      home
NewRamp © 2006 Terms Of Use